When Dic decided to make The Super Mario Bros. Super Show, Brooklyn Mario was created. He seemed to taunt King Koopa a lot, and has been a wanted fugitive ever since he destroyed the Great Wall of China in 1990. He was said to have been killed by Ludwig van Koopa in 1991, but has actually been in hiding, waiting to seek revenge on Game Mario and Koopa until he was shot by Mama Luigi. Though presumed dead, Mario lived on and tried to evade Mama Luigi and his allies. Mama Luigi became aware of his survival and sent Anime Luigi to kill him, but Anime Luigi betrayed Mama Luigi and recruited Mario into the Rebel Form Army instead. Brooklyn Mario was one of the forms who survived the Form Wars, and he soon became the king of Truceland. Unfortunately, he was killed by Secret Weapon Luigi during the Poopocalypse.
Brooklyn Mario has always had trouble getting along with Mama Luigi, often arguing with him over stuff like his favorite record, whether Rock TV is a sound financial investment, or what day Sunday is. Significantly, some of these disputes have led to the birth of forms such as Debrotherized Luigi. Over the years, he has grown increasingly intolerant of Luigi and Yoshkins' stupidity and emo-ness. He often tries and fails to help the cavemen of Dinosaur World improve their lifestyle, and is the inventor of their Cave Christmas holiday.
- "If we don't get outta here soon, we're toast."
- "It's a stone, Luigi. You didn't make it."
- "It's no time to be Italian, Luigi. Let's be Polish!"
- "Mama? Mama Luigi? Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha!"
- "King Koopa's got the princess locked up in his Coney Island Disco Palace!"
- "Free the princess, or Yoshi here will eat your castle 'till we find her."
- "Pipe number 3."
- "You'll go your way, I'll go mine."
- He is Koopa public enemy number one.
- He is related to Bizzaro Link.
- He seems to own a Stone Blaster, used to kill Mama Luigi after Mama Luigi failed to kill King Harkinian, Zelda, and Link. This proves he is not totally evil at all.
- Dic cloned his head, creating the form Brooklyn Mario Head.
- He has a seizure whenever any barbecue mammoth whip gets on his face.
- He is obsessed with Santa Claus, and he once spent $1,295.31 calling him from Brooklyn. He also has a form/alter ego called Santa Mario, which has made him a rival of King Harkinian ever since the King took over the original Santa's job.